MK Itamar Ben Gvir's decision to re-open a parliamentary office in the Sheikh Jarrah neighborhood in East Jerusalem is, more or less, a repeat of his May 2021 move, both in its characteristics and surrounding circumstances. But in May 2021 the Prime Minister was Benjamin Netanyahu, who somehow still managed to have influence over MK Ben Gvir, while today there is a government against which Ben Gvir is fighting an all-out political war.
In May 2021, the events in Sheikh Jarrah, which heightened the friction between the Israeli police and Palestinian youths at the Nablus Gate plaza during the days of Ramadan, as well as the sensitivity of the Temple Mount compound, became a platform for Hamas to embarrass the PA, change the rules of the game and the equation against Israel, and stir up the home front through Israel’s Arab sector – in what unfolded as Operation Guardian of the Walls. There is still debate over achievements of the operation, but there is no doubt that since the operation, Hamas has managed to improve its strategic position in the Palestinian arena, impose rules of the game that do not serve Israel’s long-term strategic interest, and especially to continue the processes of military buildup, while striving both to improve the terrorist infrastructure in the West Bank and southern Lebanon and to strengthen ties with Iran.
The IDF is preparing for another military round in the Gaza Strip, given the widespread assessment that such a round is not a question of “if,” but a question of “when.” Should we expect to be forced again into a military round at a time that does not suit Israel? The Israeli conduct in Sheikh Jarrah regarding the inability to lower the level of friction between Palestinians and Jews and in line with the provocations of MK Ben Gvir are a repeat of the events of May 2021, and when the theme returns, it can be assumed that even if there are some variations, it will continue to play out with the theme of its predecessor.
The combination of neglect and disregard for the potential for escalation in the Sheikh Jarrah neighborhood and unbridled provocations by irresponsible politicians who believe that with these actions they will fill the void created by the government is the recipe for another strategic failure. The fear of curbing provocations and demonstrating responsible governance is nothing short of strategic blindness and the danger of slipping on an all-too-slippery slope. Will the Israeli government see its own flaws? If it does not, the strategic price tag of hesitation may be too high.
MK Itamar Ben Gvir's decision to re-open a parliamentary office in the Sheikh Jarrah neighborhood in East Jerusalem is, more or less, a repeat of his May 2021 move, both in its characteristics and surrounding circumstances. But in May 2021 the Prime Minister was Benjamin Netanyahu, who somehow still managed to have influence over MK Ben Gvir, while today there is a government against which Ben Gvir is fighting an all-out political war.
In May 2021, the events in Sheikh Jarrah, which heightened the friction between the Israeli police and Palestinian youths at the Nablus Gate plaza during the days of Ramadan, as well as the sensitivity of the Temple Mount compound, became a platform for Hamas to embarrass the PA, change the rules of the game and the equation against Israel, and stir up the home front through Israel’s Arab sector – in what unfolded as Operation Guardian of the Walls. There is still debate over achievements of the operation, but there is no doubt that since the operation, Hamas has managed to improve its strategic position in the Palestinian arena, impose rules of the game that do not serve Israel’s long-term strategic interest, and especially to continue the processes of military buildup, while striving both to improve the terrorist infrastructure in the West Bank and southern Lebanon and to strengthen ties with Iran.
The IDF is preparing for another military round in the Gaza Strip, given the widespread assessment that such a round is not a question of “if,” but a question of “when.” Should we expect to be forced again into a military round at a time that does not suit Israel? The Israeli conduct in Sheikh Jarrah regarding the inability to lower the level of friction between Palestinians and Jews and in line with the provocations of MK Ben Gvir are a repeat of the events of May 2021, and when the theme returns, it can be assumed that even if there are some variations, it will continue to play out with the theme of its predecessor.
The combination of neglect and disregard for the potential for escalation in the Sheikh Jarrah neighborhood and unbridled provocations by irresponsible politicians who believe that with these actions they will fill the void created by the government is the recipe for another strategic failure. The fear of curbing provocations and demonstrating responsible governance is nothing short of strategic blindness and the danger of slipping on an all-too-slippery slope. Will the Israeli government see its own flaws? If it does not, the strategic price tag of hesitation may be too high.