On June 7, 2022, the Commission of Inquiry established by the UN Human Rights Council following Operation Guardian of the Walls released its first report. Due to administrative and financial constraints, the report focused on examining the findings and implementing the recommendations of previous reports. As expected, its conclusions are biased against Israel, arguing that Israel’s “occupation and discrimination" are the root causes of instability and the continuation of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Israel did not cooperate with the commission of inquiry, and strongly condemned the report's conclusions.
The report, which deals almost entirely with Israel, concentrates primarily on allegations of systematic discrimination against Palestinians, including in Israeli territory. This represents a change from previous reports that dealt with allegations of war crimes in the West Bank and Gaza, and an expression of the unprecedented, broad mandate given to the Commission of Inquiry, compared to previous ones. The report notes that the broad mandate prompted the commission to give priority to the identification of patterns, policies, and structural inequalities that lead to human rights violations and instability. According to the report, the very continuation of the occupation is the source of evil, but it is not enough to end the occupation. Rather, additional steps must be taken to ensure full equal rights for every person.
The report includes charges regarding the expansion of settlements; violence by security forces and settlers, particularly against women and girls; systematic house demolitions and evictions; Israeli legislation such as the Nation-State Law and the ban on family unification; discrimination in planning and zoning; declarations of human rights organizations as terrorist organizations; and the imposition of a siege on the Gaza Strip.
This is the first of a series of annual reports by the commission, given the broad mandate that does not specify an end date. The report states that the commission intends to conduct an independent investigation of the allegations in due course and to reach conclusions and recommendations. In this framework, information and evidence will be analyzed regarding the execution of crimes, in order to identify those with criminal responsibility and to cooperate with judicial accountability mechanisms. The commission has already mentioned that its recommendations are expected to include a call for states and private actors to impose sanctions and boycotts, hinting at what is currently underway vis-à-vis Russia.
On June 7, 2022, the Commission of Inquiry established by the UN Human Rights Council following Operation Guardian of the Walls released its first report. Due to administrative and financial constraints, the report focused on examining the findings and implementing the recommendations of previous reports. As expected, its conclusions are biased against Israel, arguing that Israel’s “occupation and discrimination" are the root causes of instability and the continuation of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Israel did not cooperate with the commission of inquiry, and strongly condemned the report's conclusions.
The report, which deals almost entirely with Israel, concentrates primarily on allegations of systematic discrimination against Palestinians, including in Israeli territory. This represents a change from previous reports that dealt with allegations of war crimes in the West Bank and Gaza, and an expression of the unprecedented, broad mandate given to the Commission of Inquiry, compared to previous ones. The report notes that the broad mandate prompted the commission to give priority to the identification of patterns, policies, and structural inequalities that lead to human rights violations and instability. According to the report, the very continuation of the occupation is the source of evil, but it is not enough to end the occupation. Rather, additional steps must be taken to ensure full equal rights for every person.
The report includes charges regarding the expansion of settlements; violence by security forces and settlers, particularly against women and girls; systematic house demolitions and evictions; Israeli legislation such as the Nation-State Law and the ban on family unification; discrimination in planning and zoning; declarations of human rights organizations as terrorist organizations; and the imposition of a siege on the Gaza Strip.
This is the first of a series of annual reports by the commission, given the broad mandate that does not specify an end date. The report states that the commission intends to conduct an independent investigation of the allegations in due course and to reach conclusions and recommendations. In this framework, information and evidence will be analyzed regarding the execution of crimes, in order to identify those with criminal responsibility and to cooperate with judicial accountability mechanisms. The commission has already mentioned that its recommendations are expected to include a call for states and private actors to impose sanctions and boycotts, hinting at what is currently underway vis-à-vis Russia.