Reducing Budget Allocations for the Arab Sector May Harm Internal Security | INSS
go to header go to content go to footer go to search
INSS logo The Institute for National Security Studies, Strategic, Innovative, Policy-Oriented Research, go to the home page
INSS
Tel Aviv University logo - beyond an external website, opens on a new page
  • Contact
  • עברית
  • Support Us
  • Research
    • Topics
      • Israel and the Global Powers
        • Israel-United States Relations
        • Glazer Israel-China Policy Center
        • Russia
        • Europe
      • Iran and the Shi'ite Axis
        • Iran
        • Lebanon and Hezbollah
        • Syria
        • Yemen and the Houthi Movement
        • Iraq and the Iraqi Shiite Militias
      • Conflict to Agreements
        • Israeli-Palestinian Relations
        • Hamas and the Gaza Strip
        • Peace Agreements and Normalization in the Middle East
        • Saudi Arabia and the Gulf States
        • Turkey
        • Egypt
        • Jordan
      • Israel’s National Security Policy
        • Military and Strategic Affairs
        • Societal Resilience and the Israeli Society
        • Jewish-Arab Relations in Israel
        • Climate, Infrastructure and Energy
        • Terrorism and Low Intensity Conflict
      • Cross-Arena Research
        • Data Analytics Center
        • Law and National Security
        • Advanced Technologies and National Security
        • Cognitive Warfare
        • Economics and National Security
    • Projects
      • Preventing the Slide into a One-State Reality
      • Contemporary Antisemitism in the United States
      • Perceptions about Jews and Israel in the Arab-Muslim World and Their Impact on the West
  • Publications
    • -
      • All Publications
      • INSS Insight
      • Policy Papers
      • Special Publication
      • Strategic Assessment
      • Technology Platform
      • Memoranda
      • Posts
      • Books
      • Archive
  • Database
    • Surveys
    • Spotlight
    • Maps
    • Real-Time Tracker
  • Events
  • Team
  • About
    • Vision and Mission
    • History
    • Research Disciplines
    • Board of Directors
    • Fellowship and Prizes
    • Internships
    • Newsletter
  • Media
    • Communications
      • Articles
      • Quotes
      • Radio and TV
    • Video gallery
    • Press Releases
  • Podcast
  • Newsletter
New
Search in site
  • Research
    • Topics
    • Israel and the Global Powers
    • Israel-United States Relations
    • Glazer Israel-China Policy Center
    • Russia
    • Europe
    • Iran and the Shi'ite Axis
    • Iran
    • Lebanon and Hezbollah
    • Syria
    • Yemen and the Houthi Movement
    • Iraq and the Iraqi Shiite Militias
    • Conflict to Agreements
    • Israeli-Palestinian Relations
    • Hamas and the Gaza Strip
    • Peace Agreements and Normalization in the Middle East
    • Saudi Arabia and the Gulf States
    • Turkey
    • Egypt
    • Jordan
    • Israel’s National Security Policy
    • Military and Strategic Affairs
    • Societal Resilience and the Israeli Society
    • Jewish-Arab Relations in Israel
    • Climate, Infrastructure and Energy
    • Terrorism and Low Intensity Conflict
    • Cross-Arena Research
    • Data Analytics Center
    • Law and National Security
    • Advanced Technologies and National Security
    • Cognitive Warfare
    • Economics and National Security
    • Projects
    • Preventing the Slide into a One-State Reality
    • Contemporary Antisemitism in the United States
    • Perceptions about Jews and Israel in the Arab-Muslim World and Their Impact on the West
  • Publications
    • All Publications
    • INSS Insight
    • Policy Papers
    • Special Publication
    • Strategic Assessment
    • Technology Platform
    • Memoranda
    • Posts
    • Books
    • Archive
  • Database
    • Surveys
    • Spotlight
    • Maps
    • Real-Time Tracker
  • Events
  • Team
  • About
    • Vision and Mission
    • History
    • Research Disciplines
    • Board of Directors
    • Fellowship and Prizes
    • Internships
  • Media
    • Communications
      • Articles
      • Quotes
      • Radio and TV
    • Video gallery
    • Press Releases
  • Podcast
  • Newsletter
  • Contact
  • עברית
  • Support Us
bool(false)

Publications

Home Publications INSS Insight Reducing Budget Allocations for the Arab Sector May Harm Internal Security

Reducing Budget Allocations for the Arab Sector May Harm Internal Security

The intention of the Finance Minister to reduce allocations from the approved five-year plan to the Arab sector lacks a professional and legal basis. In addition, it has serious immediate implications for the socio-economic status of a large segment of the Israeli population. The government must not implement these alienating plans vis-à-vis the Arab public, and should make that decision clear sooner rather than later

INSS Insight No. 1753, August 22, 2023

עברית
Ephraim Lavie
Meir Elran
Mohammed S. Wattad
Esteban Klor
Tomer Fadlon
Derek Lief

It was reported recently that the Minister of Finance intends to cut back allocations for the five-year development plans for Arab society that were already approved. These intentions contradict existing policy dating from 2015 designed to encourage socioeconomic enhancement of Arab society in Israel, based on a macroeconomic rationale and the necessary integration of the country’s large Arab minority. The explanations given are unsubstantiated and reflect an estranging approach of extreme nationalism. Realization of the Minister’s intentions, and certainly their expansion into other areas, will deal a severe blow to the Arab communities and their local authorities, the country’s economic growth, and the sensitive relations between the Jewish majority and Arab minority. It is also likely to fuel even further the rising wave of crime and violence in Arab sector and create frustration that might lead to nationalist radicalization. All this could severely erode internal security.


The intention of the Israeli government to cut back the approved budgets of the five-year plans for Arab society and East Jerusalem includes problematic legal aspects, serious economic implications, and negative consequences for relations between the Jewish majority and the Arab minority.

Five-Year Plan no. 550 for Arab Society (2022-2026) was approved in February 2023 as part of the state budget. It is based on the concept shaped by the first five-year plan for the Arab sector (922, December 2015) passed by the government headed by Benjamin Netanyahu. The initiators of the original plan understood that narrowing the social and economic gaps between the Jewish majority and the Arab minority in Israel was a long-term strategic objective that would serve as a lever for the social and economic integration of Arabs in the country. The defining objective was to bring about fundamental and ongoing transformation in government policy toward the Arab sector, which would generate growth in the Israeli national economy. The new policy was distinguished by the permanent enactment of the principle of allocating budgets to the Arab population according to its relative size in the population as a whole.

The current intention of Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich to freeze budgets for Arab local authorities (and his failed attempt to cut state resources for Palestinian students of East Jerusalem), as well as the demand of far right parties to halt Five-Year Plan 550, allegedly for the sake of re-examining its components, contradicts this profound transformative strategy and is explained by unprofessional and unfounded arguments:

  1. Regarding the reduced budget allocations to Arab local authorities, the Finance Minister claimed that portions of the budgets trickle through to criminal organizations. This ignores the comprehensive work submitted (May 2022) for the “Secure Route” program of the previous government, designed to create secure funding channels for Arab local authorities. All that remained to be done was to implement the proposed mechanisms to control the funding procedures.
  2. The intention to review Five-Year Plan 550 before implementation is based on the claim that the budgets were allocated by the previous government in the framework of coalition agreements, which amount to “a problematic continuation of a policy of discrimination against Jews, giving unprecedented control to anti-Zionist elements within government ministries.” However, the plan was approved as part of the state budget.
  3. On the Five-Year Plan for 2023-2028 for East Jerusalem, approved by the government on May 23, 2023: the confirmed resolution states that “narrowing the gaps…is a national challenge and a government objective of prime importance…The development and prosperity of Jerusalem…for the benefit of all its citizens…is based on the integration of East Jerusalem residents into the fabric of urban life and Israeli society.” Referring to his intention to halt the budget for academic preparatory programs in Israeli institutions of higher education for Palestinians living in East Jerusalem, the Finance Minister claimed that these programs encourage incitement and reinforce dangerous nationalist attitudes. This claim has no factual basis. Experience shows that not only do these programs not encourage terror, but they promote normative integration of Palestinians. Data provided by the Israeli Bureau of Statistics shows that since the initiation of this program in 2018 until 2023, the number of Palestinian students from East Jerusalem who study in Israel for the first year of their BA surged by 85 percent (to 1,218 students). Degrees from Israeli academic institutions facilitate graduates’ integration in the Israeli labor market and helps restrain nationalist tension. Thus, abolition of these programs might presumably increase nationalist tension in East Jerusalem, one of the country’s poorest areas and a hotbed of nationalist friction. On Augst 17 it was reported that the budget for this program will not be cut and will be allocated "to encourage higher education for Arab youth," though it is not yet clear what is the practical meaning of this new statement.

In principle, intentions to reduce budgets for the development of the Arab sector, even if not fully implemented, are evidence of nationalist anti-Arab ideology.

Legal Aspects

The announced intentions of the Finance Minister amount to a flagrant legal violation and failure to respect the decisions of the previous government. Continuity of governance is one of the basic principles of public law in Israel and an important principle in any democratic regime that wishes to ensure regime stability. The principle of relying on government commitments is even more important in a democratic parliamentary system like Israel’s, which lacks a clear constitutional framework and where Knesset elections take place more frequently than once every four years. Another aspect is linked to the principle of government’s obligation to attend to all sections of the population equally. Violation of commitments of a previous government on the basis of political, ethnic, or religious identity is a severe blow to the principle of equality.

Economic and Social Implications

The immediate price of the decisions under discussion, if implemented, will constitute genuine damage to the provision of essential services to the Arab population and a halt to essential development processes that began in recent years. This would harm the local Arab authorities and the development of growth engines for a weakened sector of the population. The assumption that it is possible to rule a minority by isolating it economically is mistaken, and could, rather, have the opposite effect: an increased sense of frustration, alienation, and hatred mixed with nationalism might well lead to violence. This might be particularly the case at a time when Arab society in Israel is experiencing extreme levels of crime and violence.

The specific intention to freeze the transfer of budgets to Arab local authorities, which are already suffering from a lack of funding, might be fatal for them. Data from the Central Bureau of Statistics, showing the gap in revenues between Jewish and Arab towns, highlights the importance of releasing these budgets. Collection of city taxes in Arab towns is on average four times lower than in Jewish towns, due to their lower socioeconomic status and the absence of significant revenues from business. Over the years, low revenues have affected the inadequate provision of education and welfare services by the Arab local authorities, and thus perpetuated the social gaps. Moreover, the Arab local authorities have already planned their budgets based on the government allocations under the five-year plan. Without this income, their deficits will grow, and the central government will be called on to cover them from the national budget.

The expected erosion in the provision of basic services to Arab citizens will impact their standard of living: the deep gaps in education between Arabs and Jews will widen, after they had begun to narrow; the goal in the five-year plan for digital literacy and language skills in Hebrew and English will also be affected; and reduction in allocations for housing will limit the availability of state land for construction of housing and public institutions, adding barriers in the field of urban planning, and weakening local authority planning committees and engineering units.

Cutting the municipal services could also impede dealing with the challenge of young people out of school or jobs, thus furthering the rise in violence and crime in Arab society. Since the start of the year there has been an unprecedented surge in crime, with the number of murders more than double the already high figures of previous years. The link between poverty, violence, and crime, particularly in Arab society in Israel, is known and has been proven. Presumably a decrease in financial aid for Arab society will lead to frustration and anger against the Jewish public and government, which will be reflected in ever more serious violence and crime that might also spread to Jewish areas.

Conclusion and Recommendations

Since the formation of the current government, concern among the Arab population has grown about an institutional decline in its situation. Reports of planned cutbacks in the five-year plan make these concerns more concrete, direct, and blatant. At this stage the impact of the cuts is not still fully clear, but the long-term trend is apparent: increased separation and discrimination against Arabs in Israel, based on nationalist considerations. The ostensible justifications for these intentions are telling. This attitude, if continued, will amount to a strategic change for the worse and severely harm relations between the country’s majority and a significant minority.

For the State of Israel, a country that is home to a large national minority that is part of the Palestinian people, who are perceived by many as an “enemy,” such a change in the relations between Jews and Arabs might have far-reaching negative consequences. Apart from questions of principles and ideology with reference to democracy, equality, and human rights, the change also involves highly sensitive and potentially dangerous social and security issues. An evolution from a clear policy of integration to an aggressive approach of alienation and discrimination, using the power of the state against a weakened national minority, is likely to encourage nationalist extremism on both sides and harm national security.

The government must therefore refrain from implementing these intentions and return to the constructive approach led by previous governments since 2015. It must work hard to retrieve what has already been damaged: the Arab public’s trust in the state and the government. Attacks on basic principles of equality and respect for the minority could lead to chaos and widespread violence. Such harmful moves must also be stopped because of their negative impact on Israel’s international image, particularly in the United States, including among the Jewish community there.

The opinions expressed in INSS publications are the authors’ alone.
Publication Series INSS Insight
TopicsJewish-Arab Relations in Israel
עברית

Events

All events
The 18th Annual International Conference
25 February, 2025
08:15 - 16:00

Related Publications

All publications
Shutterstock
Neglecting the Struggle Against Crime in Arab Society Is a Threat to Israel’s National Security
Against the backdrop of the ongoing war, which has lasted for 8 months, it appears that the problem of crime in Arab society is noticeably absent from the list of priorities of the Israeli government and the law enforcement system. With over 100 murders in the Arab sector during the first half of the year, the persistent neglect in combating the growing violence has dangerous implications for Israel’s national security
26/06/24
Mostafa Alkharouf / Anadolu Agency
Between Restraint and Protest: Arab Society in Israel After Seven Months of War
After seven months of war in Gaza, calm has been maintained between the Jewish and Arab sectors in Israel—even during the month of Ramadan, despite concerns expressed by the security and political establishments. However, amid the harsh reality of the ongoing war, potential dangers could undermine the stability of these delicate relations. What are these dangers, and how should they be addressed?
19/05/24
REUTERS/Carlos Barria
Cutting the Budgets for the Arab Sector’s Five-Year Plans Threatens Israel’s National Security and Resilience
Despite the need for budget cuts across the board because of the war in Gaza, a significant cut in the five-year plans for Arab society could severely harm not only Arab society but also the Israeli economy and national security
07/02/24

Stay up to date

Registration was successful! Thanks.
  • Research

    • Topics
      • Israel and the Global Powers
      • Israel-United States Relations
      • Glazer Israel-China Policy Center
      • Russia
      • Europe
      • Iran and the Shi'ite Axis
      • Iran
      • Lebanon and Hezbollah
      • Syria
      • Yemen and the Houthi Movement
      • Iraq and the Iraqi Shiite Militias
      • Conflict to Agreements
      • Israeli-Palestinian Relations
      • Hamas and the Gaza Strip
      • Peace Agreements and Normalization in the Middle East
      • Saudi Arabia and the Gulf States
      • Turkey
      • Egypt
      • Jordan
      • Israel’s National Security Policy
      • Military and Strategic Affairs
      • Societal Resilience and the Israeli Society
      • Jewish-Arab Relations in Israel
      • Climate, Infrastructure and Energy
      • Terrorism and Low Intensity Conflict
      • Cross-Arena Research
      • Data Analytics Center
      • Law and National Security
      • Advanced Technologies and National Security
      • Cognitive Warfare
      • Economics and National Secutiry
    • Projects
      • Preventing the Slide into a One-State Reality
      • Contemporary Antisemitism in the United States
      • Perceptions about Jews and Israel in the Arab-Muslim World and Their Impact on the West
  • Publications

    • All Publications
    • INSS Insight
    • Policy Papers
    • Special Publication
    • Strategic Assessment
    • Technology Platform
    • Memoranda
    • Database
    • Posts
    • Books
    • Archive
  • About

    • Vision and Mission
    • History
    • Research Disciplines
    • Board of Directors
    • Fellowship and Prizes
    • Internships
    • Support
  • Media

    • Communications
    • Articles
    • Quotes
    • Radio and TV
    • Video Gallery
    • Press Release
    • Podcast
  • Home

  • Events

  • Database

  • Team

  • Contact

  • Newsletter

  • עברית

INSS logo The Institute for National Security Studies, Strategic, Innovative, Policy-Oriented Research, go to the home page
40 Haim Levanon St. Tel Aviv, 6997556 Israel | Tel: 03-640-0400 | Fax: 03-744-7590 | Email: info@inss.org.il
Developed by Daat A Realcommerce company.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.